After an embarrassing NLDS exit, the Philadelphia Phillies are facing a crucial offseason. Despite a strong regular season where they went 95-67 and clinched their first NL East title since 2011, their postseason run fell far short of expectations, as they managed only one playoff win. With an offense that fizzled out and a bullpen that collapsed, big changes are necessary to fix the team’s shortcomings.
While the Phillies’ core—featuring stars like Bryce Harper, Trea Turner, Zack Wheeler, and Aaron Nola—remains intact on lucrative contracts, the team must make tough decisions on the supporting cast to improve for the 2025 season. Manager Rob Thomson and the front office are expected to make major moves, and some familiar faces won’t be returning.
Here are three key players the Phillies are cutting ties with as they look to retool for next season.
3. Kolby Allard to Be Non-Tendered
Kolby Allard was signed last offseason as pitching depth, but his impact was minimal. In seven appearances, including four starts, Allard posted a disappointing 5.00 ERA over 27 innings. While he showed flashes of potential, his inconsistent performances left much to be desired.
Set to enter arbitration and out of minor league options, Allard’s future with the team appears bleak. The Phillies are unlikely to offer him a contract above the $1 million he earned last year, especially with cheaper options available. Allard will likely be non-tendered, leaving him as a free agent unless he returns on a minor league deal.
2. Austin Hays Trade Proves Unsuccessful
At the trade deadline, Phillies GM Dave Dombrowski brought in several players to bolster the team for a postseason push. One of those additions was Austin Hays, acquired to provide a right-handed bat to complement lefty Brandon Marsh, who struggles against left-handed pitchers.
Unfortunately, Hays failed to make an impact, posting a .672 OPS in just 22 games with the Phillies. He also missed time due to injury and was outshined by Weston Wilson, who performed better against left-handed pitching. Though Hays has one more year of team control, his $6.3 million salary for next season makes him a likely non-tender candidate as the Phillies look for more production at a similar price point.
1. Phillies Seek Upgrade at Backup Catcher, Garrett Stubbs Likely Out
J.T. Realmuto, once the undisputed best catcher in baseball, is beginning to show signs of decline as he approaches 34 years of age. While still effective, he missed time due to injury and wasn’t his usual self in the postseason. The Phillies need a reliable backup catcher to help shoulder the load as Realmuto’s playing time is managed more carefully.
Garrett Stubbs, a fan favorite and clubhouse presence, has provided some fun moments during his time in Philadelphia, but his production at the plate has been underwhelming. In 54 games this season, he slashed just .207/.296/.262 with one home run and 11 RBIs. Though Stubbs is strong defensively and offers speed, the Phillies need a more productive backup catcher.
While Stubbs will be missed in the locker room, the Phillies may turn to Rafael Marchan or explore other options to upgrade behind the plate.
Leave a Reply