Does a Jack Campbell-for-Elvis Merzlikins trade make too much sense not to happen?
In recent developments, the Columbus Blue Jackets’ goaltender, Elvis Merzlikins, seems to be on the verge of a move. While Merzlikins emphasized that he hasn’t explicitly requested a trade, both he and the team have mutually agreed to explore new possibilities. Despite his affection for Columbus, the 29-year-old netminder is adamant about being treated as a No. 1 goalie and has expressed his unwillingness to serve as a backup. This has prompted discussions about potential destinations for Merzlikins and the viability of a trade.
One plausible destination is Edmonton, where Merzlikins could potentially compete with Stuart Skinner for the starting goalie position. However, several factors complicate this scenario. Merzlikins has three years remaining on his current contract with an annual cap hit of $5.4 million, making him a challenging player to move. Moreover, his previous inconsistent performances in the last two seasons and a 10-team no-trade list further complicate matters. In Edmonton, he would face fierce competition from Skinner, adding an additional layer of uncertainty to his potential role.
On the flip side, a trade involving the Toronto Maple Leafs’ goaltender Jack Campbell for Merzlikins makes significant sense. Both players have similar contracts, with Campbell earning $5.0 million per year for the next three seasons, only $400,000 less than Merzlikins. Both goalies have struggled in their current environments and could benefit from a change of scenery. Additionally, a trade between the two could potentially rejuvenate their careers and provide a fresh start.
However, the question arises: would other teams be interested in acquiring Merzlikins without sending back a similarly burdensome contract? The number of NHL teams capable of absorbing Merzlikins’ contract without a comparable return is limited. Chicago, Buffalo, Anaheim, and Nashville are potential suitors, but Merzlikins’ no-trade list and their willingness to accept his cap hit could complicate negotiations. Carolina, desperate for goaltending help, might consider Merzlikins, but the length and cost of his contract could be deterrents.
While various teams could be potential destinations for Merzlikins, the trade dynamics involve multiple factors, including his preferences and the willingness of other teams to accept his contract. Carolina stands out as a team in need of goaltending, but the three-year commitment might be a deterrent. Chicago could be a contender, although they already have a reliable starter in Petr Mrazek.
The Edmonton Oilers, despite the potential fit, face their own set of considerations. Stuart Skinner’s exceptional performance and the reliability of backup Calvin Pickard raise questions about disrupting the current goaltending situation. The Oilers must weigh the potential benefits of acquiring Merzlikins against the stability offered by their current tandem.
Ultimately, the trade speculation raises intriguing possibilities, with Merzlikins and Campbell emerging as prominent figures in potential goalie swaps. The Oilers, seeking a reliable option to support Skinner, may find merit in exploring the feasibility of a trade that could reshape their goaltending dynamics for the better. However, careful consideration of all factors, including Merzlikins’ role and preferences, remains crucial in determining the viability of such a move.
Leave a Reply